Yves right here. John Helmer offers an in depth and informative overview of details about the Crocus bloodbath, specializing in accounts from the Russian facet. One side that options prominently right here, and so far as I can inform, has been uncared for in Western studies, is the position of the hearth and constructing collapse within the deaths and casualties. Helmer notes that the 4 shooters left earlier than they’d gotten midway by their ammo, suggesting they left to flee the blaze. There are additionally accusations in Russia that the theater was out of compliance with a number of fire-risk-reducing necessities, compounded by means of low cost and significantly flammable Chinese language supplies.
By John Helmer, the longest repeatedly serving international correspondent in Russia, and the one western journalist to direct his personal bureau impartial of single nationwide or business ties. Helmer has additionally been a professor of political science, and an advisor to authorities heads in Greece, america, and Asia. He’s the primary and solely member of a US presidential administration (Jimmy Carter) to determine himself in Russia. Initially printed at Dances with Bears
In simply 13 minutes, 4 Kalashnikov rifles, knives, and plastic bottles of gasoline, discharged by 4 males, weren’t sufficient to kill and injure so many individuals as have been accounted for thus far within the Crocus Metropolis Corridor assault in Moscow.
Greater than half these examined up to now in post-mortems “died on account of the hearth from publicity to excessive temperature and combustion merchandise”, in accordance to Alexander Bastrykin, the chief investigator in his public report back to President Vladimir Putin on Monday night time. Publish-mortems have but to be reported for one-third of the 139 useless counted by Bastrykin; no evaluation of the reason for accidents to 182 of the surviving casualties has been reported but; 93 of them stay in hospital.
Bastrykin additionally reported “two AK-74 assault rifles, over 500 rounds of ammunition, 28 magazines with ammunition, and bottles with remaining gasoline had been discovered and seized on the scene.” A NATO army professional explains: “They didn’t strike me as well-trained, so that they misplaced time altering magazines and their fireplace wasn’t all that correct. These information inform me the vast majority of victims died from another trigger than gunshot.”
Yevgeny Krutikov, a author with army intelligence sources, reported in Vzglyad: “It may be assumed that the weapons had been saved within the terrorists’ cache for a very long time and never too rigorously – the machine weapons sparkled through the capturing. This means harm to the barrel or breech (filth acquired contained in the barrel).”
Recruitment of the shooters; pre-placement of weapons and ammunition; lodging and advance cost to the gunmen; buy of the automotive they used; communications and coordination; exit undetected within the crowds escaping the constructing; and the escape path to the Ukraine border by Bryansk area – the proof of those particulars ready over weeks and months point out a a lot bigger group than the 4 shooters shaped with seven others already arrested and below interrogation.
What they know and can inform is more likely to reveal a classy command-and-control system which knew how susceptible the goal was, find out how to maximize the killing within the shortest potential length, and on the identical time permit escape for the attackers – which is sort of unprecedented within the latest historical past of mass terrorist assaults in Russia. .
That’s to say, the command knew — the shooters and their accomplices didn’t. There was advance reconnoiter of the Crocus Metropolis Corridor in order that the shooters knew the route they adopted contained in the constructing after which out below cowl of fireside and smoke, which erupted sooner than they had been in a position to shoot virtually half of their ammunition which they left behind.
Did the command additionally know that Crocus Metropolis Corridor and the encircling mall had been working with out satisfactory fireplace alarms, smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, sprinklers, and emergency air flow, none of which has been reported by eyewitnesses? Was the constructing focused as a result of the command knew it was constructed with out fire-resistant structural helps, permitting ceilings and roof to collapse, choking or crushing these beneath to dying?
“A lot of the victims in Crocus died not by the hands of terrorists, however from the prison negligence of the house owners and regulatory authorities,” reported Mikhail Delyagin, chairman of the State Duma Committee on Financial Coverage, on Sunday night. “It’s recognized that many individuals suffocated with carbon monoxide contained in the constructing. There are already extra victims of this sort than these killed by terrorist capturing. Nothing like this might occur in a licensed constructing constructed in line with trendy requirements for such objects. Why? As a result of all such buildings are outfitted with an computerized air flow system. These are home windows or hatches that fireplace off routinely if the detector detects an elevated stage of carbon monoxide inside. Holes open within the roof – and the life-threatening fuel goes into the sky. This technique works, by the way in which, with out electrical energy, on compressed air.”
“The way in which the Crocus burned down reveals that low cost Chinese language supplies (glass wool, plastics, cable braid, and many others.) had been utilized in its ornament, that are prohibited to be used in public buildings. The rationale for the ban? Combustibility. In Europe, non-burning glass wool, plastics, and many others. have been used for a very long time. They’re, in fact, twice or 3 times costlier than the Chinese language equal. However they’ve one benefit: they don’t burn in case of fireside. They usually don’t kill those that are inside.”
Delyagin has publicly accused Aras Agalarov, the rich founding father of the Crocus purchasing and improvement group, and his son Emin of failing “to formally fee this specific live performance corridor. Because it turned recognized, it isn’t listed as a correctly designed capital development object on the cadastral map of the Federal Register. Apparently, the quantity of bribes wanted to obtain such a harmful object exceeded all cheap limits, and for Agalarov, bearing in mind the above-mentioned monstrous violations of requirements, it was cheaper to increase the standing of a constructing below development than to place it into operation.”
Bastrykin has introduced “the investigation is checking the opportunity of violation of security necessities and the hearth extinguishing system within the Crocus Metropolis Corridor live performance corridor. For this function, distant controls, digital parts and management gadgets for the hearth safety system of the live performance corridor had been seized. They’re geared toward researching and extracting details about the working mode of fireside security techniques on the time of the terrorist assault. The contents of the hearth safety system server are being studied with the participation of specialists. To determine the operability and well timed operation of all fireplace security techniques, a hearth technical examination has been appointed.”
Emin Agalarov has issued a press assertion claiming he arrived earlier than the gunmen had left. He mentioned he “entered the constructing 40 minutes after the primary photographs had been fired. He famous that the hearth security system was working and the doorways had been unlocked…The sprinkler fireplace extinguishing system was additionally working usually. The constructing collapsed solely six hours after the beginning of the horrible fireplace. Some rooms remained intact and didn’t burn down.”
“If we focus too arduous on the minute particulars that are being patched collectively, this may clear up some particulars of assault,” feedback a retired senior intelligence supply ready to know, “we would be taught one thing extra however not the basics. These [the four shooters] are not any ISIS-Okay. . The more durable New York Occasions, BBC and The Guardian attempt to show they’re, the much less we now have to consider it. They’re no jihadists. Simply murderers. Mercenaries introduced in a month in the past.
They aren’t suicide killers. There are not any studies of this ISIS outfit working away from Afghanistan and Pakistan. Definitely not in Tajikistan. Nevertheless there are mercenaries at a dime a dozen there who’ve fought throughout. Together with in ISIS.”
“At Ukraine entry, they will surely have been killed, eradicating all of the proof. The investigation will present they had been employed, paid for. A Tajikistan blogger information service reported raids in [Tajik] villages, however then eliminated it. I’m positive their households and pals might be picked up and all connections to jihadists or contractors might be established. They aren’t migrants, don’t converse Russian, and thus can not declare any ethnic discrimination vendetta [against Russians].”
President Putin claimed in his assembly with the safety providers on Monday: “We all know that the crime was perpetrated by radical Islamists. The Islamic world itself has been combating this ideology for hundreds of years. However we’re additionally seeing how america is utilizing totally different channels to try to persuade its satellites and different nations of the world that, in line with its intelligence, there’s supposedly no signal of Kiev’s involvement within the Moscow terrorist assault, that the lethal terrorist assault was perpetrated by followers of Islam, members of ISIS, an organisation banned in Russia. We all know whose fingers had been used to commit this atrocity in opposition to Russia and its individuals. We need to know who ordered it.”
What Putin meant by “radical Islamists” is unclear; the general public proof of the 4 people who’ve been charged has but to verify a document of their religiosity or any ideological conviction.
The officers on the Kremlin assembly on Monday: Prosecutor-Basic Igor Krasnov, Chief of Workers of the Presidential Govt Workplace Anton Vaino, First Deputy Chief of the Presidential Govt Workplace Sergei Kiriyenko, Deputy Prime Minister Tatyana Golikova, Presidential aide Maxim Oreshkin, Inside Minister Vladimir Kolokoltsev, Emergencies Minister Alexander Kurenkov, Minister of Labour and Social Safety Anton Kotyakov, Healthcare Minister Mikhail Murashko, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov, Director of the Federal Safety Service Alexander Bortnikov, Commander of the Nationwide Guard Troops Viktor Zolotov, Chairman of the Investigative Committee Alexander Bastrykin, Moscow Area Governor Andrei Vorobiev, and Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin. Supply: http://en.kremlin.ru/
In the meanwhile, the one proof connecting the 4 shooters to the Ukraine is the path they had been taking when their automobile was stopped by the safety forces. In a shootout the automotive overturned, and three of the gunmen fled into the forest beside the highway, leaving one man injured within the automotive.
The pinnacle of the State Duma Committee on Data Coverage, Alexander Khinshtein, is the supply for press reporting on the location of the interception. That was on Freeway E101 about seven kilometres south of the P-120 intersection east of Bryansk metropolis. From Bastrykin’s report, and from an award ceremony in Bryansk on Monday for the forces who made the seize – Federal Safety Service (FSB), Inside Ministry, Nationwide Guard, and border forces of the Protection Ministry — the getaway was being tracked for a while earlier than it reached the P-120 intersection. At that time, if the 4 males deliberate to go for Belarus, they’d have turned proper, adopted the south round highway round Bryansk, after which turned left on to the A-240 in the direction of the Belarus border, about 100 kms to the southwest.
As a substitute, the lads drove due south and on the freeway close to Khatsun, they had been about 100 kms from the Ukraine border. There have been studies they had been anticipating to make a rendezvous with accomplices they believed would information them to security over the Ukraine border, and to payday. Or, as Moscow sources speculate, to their execution by the Ukrainians.
Above: Google map of the roads and villages, together with Khatsun, east of Bryansk metropolis. Under: the view in daylight of the purpose on Freeway E-101 the place the gunmen had been intercepted about 5 minutes after they handed the Belarus turnoff, confirming to the safety forces monitoring the automotive that they had been heading to the Ukraine.
Hypothesis, nonetheless, together with evaluation of the cui bono, who positive factors kind, the sequence of statements from Washington, and the historical past of affiliation between the US, British and Ukrainian secret providers and Tajik mercenaries, creates a steadiness of chances, however not an evidence past cheap doubt.
“After all, we should additionally reply the query of why the terrorists, after committing their crime, tried to flee particularly to Ukraine,” the president mentioned at his assembly with safety officers on Monday. “Who was ready for them there? It’s clear that these supporting the Kiev regime don’t want to be implicated in acts of terrorism and be seen as sponsors of terrorism. However there are certainly quite a few questions.”
Public feedback to reporters on Tuesday by the FSB chief Alexander Bortnikov and Safety Council Secretary Nikolai Patrushev have answered with emphasis on the Ukrainians, backed by the US and UK.
Supply: https://t.me/s/boris_rozhin March 26 – 15:34.
Boris Rozhin (Colonel Cassad) has adopted their remarks with an in depth assertion of the historical past of the intelligence service operations earlier than the Crocus assault, and a circumstantial element of Ukrainian border drone operations within the space and on the night time the getaway automotive was headed by Bryansk area. Click on to learn – March 26, Min 22: 23.
What is clear up to now, together with from the road of Tajik accomplices now making formal appearances in a Moscow courtroom, is the absence of ideology or religiosity of the unconventional Islamic kind; and ignorance of the place their orders and cash had been coming from, and why. This non-evidence factors to the Ukraine as strongly because the highway the 4 shooters had been taking after they had been caught.
Their subsequent manner in short videoclips after seize, in hospital, and in courtroom confirms what the army blogger Boris Rozhin calls “dumb hysteria…behaviour [that is] typical in a state of affairs the place the actions of terrorists shouldn’t have a deep ideological foundation. That is the case of the Crocus gunmen, the place the only real motivation is simply cash. Already within the second of flight, the criminals realized what they’d dedicated and, because the terrorist assault was not supported by ideology, the militants had been seized with animal concern for their very own lives. Subsequently, through the interrogation, they’re prepared to inform all the pieces, cry and so forth, simply to remain alive.”
The Russian intelligence company investigations now below method, in accordance to Krutikov, are tracing the “Telegram accounts by which the terrorists acquired directions, together with throughout their departure from the crime scene. Most definitely, it’s this department which instantly hyperlinks the investigation with the Ukrainian path as a result of indication of a particular sq. on the border crossing.”
The general public recriminations in opposition to the Agalarov household aren’t supported by Alexander Kurenkov, the Emergencies Minister, who informed the Kremlin assembly on Monday in a quick, ambiguous report: “The constructing was outfitted with an computerized fireplace alarm system. This technique responded to the hearth as anticipated. There was additionally a set of 4 robotized fire-fighting hoses and a software program management system, which labored at the side of different fireplace safety techniques. They had been activated through the terrorist assault, however the arson concerned using flammable substances. In keeping with specialists, the system did not extinguish the hearth as a consequence of its extensive unfold. That is what I wished to say. We managed to completely extinguish the hearth on wall panels, given the supplies they had been fabricated from, solely at 6.40 pm at present [March 25]. The search and rescue operations proceed. They’re anticipated to be accomplished by 5 pm tomorrow [March 26]. This concludes my report.”
An Emergencies Ministry (MChS) professional has launched information indicating the hearth coated 12,900 sq. metres and greater than 900 cubic metres of collapsed constructions had been eliminated. Within the videoclip the roofless exterior wall might be seen, and the destruction of the internal auditorium.
Supply: https://www.kommersant.ru
A neighborhood fireplace brigade supply feedback: “this was a Class-5 fireplace — Class 5 is an excessive fireplace hazard — and the providers did a very skilled job to comprise and extinguish a hearth of such depth.” He mentioned the roof “could have collapsed between 2:30 am and three:30 am.” This corroborates Emin Agalarov’s report of the timing.
The fireplace professional defined: “If a number of gasoline was spilled within the auditorium among the many chairs with artificial cloth and plastic parts, then even low-inflammable issues might begin burning. They’re immune to excessive temperatures, however to not extraordinarily excessive ones. On this case the sprinkler system might be ineffective.”
The Moscow area governor, Andrei Vorobiev (Vorobyov), was on the website half an hour after the gang had left. “An operational headquarters has been established. All the small print will come later.” At 10:39 on Saturday night [March 23] he reported by video that the roof was nonetheless ablaze and that firefighters had been pouring water on it from extension ladders.
Governor Vorobiev is at decrease left. Supply: https://t.me/vorobiev_live/6164
Six hours later, at 04:43, Vorobiev posted a brand new video clip from contained in the constructing wherein he confirmed with firemen that the roof had fallen in. “The collapse of constructions continues now,” Vorobiev reported. “There are nonetheless some pockets of fireside, however a lot of the fireplace has been eradicated. Rescuers had been in a position to enter the auditorium, the place the temperature had been excessive for a very long time and the place, apparently, the epicentre of the hearth was. The roof over the auditorium has collapsed, and the particles continues to be being dismantled.”
Supply: https://t.me/vorobiev_live/6170
Delyagin was requested to say if he wished to appropriate his preliminary report and modify his allegations in opposition to the Agalarovs; he has not answered.
The political repercussions of the assault have been amplified within the Moscow media. However at a gathering of the Prosecutor-Basic’s Workplace Board on Tuesday, Putin performed down his declare about “radical Islamists” of the day earlier than. “As you understand,” he mentioned, “the perpetrators answerable for this mass homicide have been arrested, and our regulation enforcement businesses are diligently investigating the circumstances surrounding this barbaric crime. They’re piecing collectively the small print of the assault, figuring out the roles and culpability of every particular person concerned, and analyzing the findings offered by criminalists and specialists. The Federal Safety Service [FSB], alongside different intelligence providers, is actively addressing pertinent points in coordination with the Nationwide Anti-Terrorism Committee.”
The president added: “I belief that the prosecutors, inside the scope of their authority, will make sure that justice is served when charging the accused and through the authorized proceedings.” This seems to be a response to western media studies that the 4 gunmen had been overwhelmed up and tortured after their seize.
Prosecutor-Basic Igor Krasnov mentioned to Putin: “These atrocities have a standard objective – to intimidate individuals, to destroy the unity of our individuals. Their performers, clients and curators will inevitably be punished. That’s the reason a very powerful activity for Russia stays to attain the targets of a particular army operation.” Putin had mentioned the identical factor the day earlier than: “Their objective, as I discussed, is to sow panic in our society whereas demonstrating to their very own folks that not all hope is misplaced for the Kiev regime. All they should do is comply with the orders of their Western patrons, battle till the final Ukrainian, obey Washington’s instructions, endorse the brand new mobilization regulation, and type one thing resembling a brand new model of the Hitler Youth. To adjust to all of this, they may search new weapons and extra funds, a lot of which can probably be embezzled and, as is customary in Ukraine at present, put into their very own pockets.”
As extra time has elapsed and the interrogations of the assault group have produced no new official proof, the Russian media have been publishing offended calls to limit migration into Russia, each authorized and unlawful; assaults on ethnic communities just like the Tajiks; and on the corruption of Russian officers offering them with entry, residence, and work permits. The Kremlin has responded with a quick communiqué of a phone name between Putin and the Tajikistan President Emomali Rahmon: “In the course of the dialog, Vladimir Putin and Emomali Rahmon famous that the safety providers of Russia and Tajikistan had been working intently collectively to counter terrorism and that they’d construct up their cooperation.”
Konstantin Malofeev (Malofeyev), proprietor of the Tsargrad media group in Moscow, has printed a number of coverage calls below the slogan, “the inner menace has turned out to be no much less critical than the exterior one”. “There must be no xenophobia in the direction of Ukrainians, Jews, and Muslims,” in line with Malofeev. “We’re a multinational nation. That’s the one purpose she turned an Empire. As a result of she will not be solely robust, but additionally type. And xenophobia is the lot of the weak. The robust aren’t afraid. However a reliable migration coverage, in fact, should be carried out. There must be no migration enclaves. There must be no diasporas which attempt to change the federal government, whom the federal government consults and fears. Members of those diasporas shouldn’t be above the regulation. If they arrive to Russia, then the principle factor for them must be the regulation.”
“Think about what three million ‘hardworking’ migrants would do in Moscow, for instance, if all of them got here out directly… It’s not a bell anymore – it’s a bell ringing, a rumble. It’s time to take up migration laws. Solely on this case will we have the ability to defend ourselves. Fortuitously, I’ve proof that the individuals in energy who’re answerable for migration have heard this ringing. I hope this may have an effect on our streets and our security. I hope that we’ll now not need to catch Tajiks 100 kilometres from the Ukrainian border who can not converse Russian, however on the identical time stay freely in Russia.”
Dwelling web page of Tsargrad illustrated with a collage of armed Tajik fighters showing to pose in entrance of the Kremlin; Konstantin Malofeev is pictured at higher proper. For extra on how Malofeev made his first fortune, click on to learn this and the archive.
Putin responded swiftly in his speech to prosecutors on Tuesday; the State Duma adopted. “[Prosecutors should] think about implementing a system of extra preventive and anti-crime measures,” the president mentioned, “together with supervision of compliance with migration laws. The state of affairs on this space, which is essential and of nice concern to hundreds of thousands of individuals, should be intently monitored.” The identical day, Vyacheslav Volodin, the Duma Speaker, informed a parliamentary session that he’s appointing a multi-party working group “that can analyze the whole vary of laws that’s related to the challenges of at present, and laws within the area of migration.”
Professional-US reporters in Moscow reverse the path of the crackdown Malofeev and his supporters advocate. “Russians will probably face the safety crackdown that, satirically [sic], they’ve largely averted over two years of conflict in Ukraine. That will imply an additional tightening of the screws on speech and make it a lot more durable to make use of public transportation or collect in massive teams. Communities of migrant employees will probably face an actual crackdown… the techniques as soon as adopted to take care of terrorists turned shortly accepted as a brand new norm to deal with political dissent. Thus the torture the Russian safety providers used in opposition to 4 suspects is likely to be used in opposition to all type of individuals within the nation. That is essentially the most direct consequence of the assault.”
Malofeev and the Tsargrad group aren’t alone in saying the Crocus Metropolis Corridor assault ought to result in intensification of the army operations within the Ukraine. “They struck at us, at our civilians, furthermore, within the very heart of our Homeland. That is an act of conflict. It must be answered as we now have mentioned many occasions. It should lastly be answered with the huge actual use of weapons that can permit us to win this conflict. We should give the civilian inhabitants [in the Ukraine] 48 hours to go away the cities after which strike with all our may. Then the conflict will finish shortly, which signifies that the sponsorship of terrorist assaults will cease. No Individuals and British, with out the Armed Forces of Ukraine, with out Kiev, with out the present conflict, will sponsor terrorist assaults on the territory of Russia.”
In the meanwhile, there was no affect of the Crocus assault and the Moscow media debate on the operational or strategic plans below method within the Ukraine. The intensification of the Basic Workers’s offensive alongside the road of contact within the Donbass; within the electrical conflict in opposition to Kharkov and different cities east of the Dnieper River; and within the missile assaults on targets from Kiev to Lvov – reported right here — commenced earlier than the Moscow occasions; they’re persevering with as deliberate.
“These in political command who’ve been favouring an end result to the conflict that falls wanting regime change in Kiev and extension of demilitarization to the Polish border,” observes a Moscow political supply, “have misplaced their voice since Saturday night time.”
