As reported by China’s Ministry of Commerce, in 2023 complete on-line retail gross sales amounted to fifteen.4 trillion yuan ($2.1 trillion), a rise of 11 %, marking China’s eleventh consecutive 12 months because the world’s largest on-line retail market. In the meantime, the fast growth of e-commerce has facilitated the adoption of assorted misleading methods to focus on a broader buyer base, giving rise to important considerations.
Misleading Practices on China’s On-line Retail Platforms
The prevalent misleading practices on China’s on-line retail platforms primarily fall into two classes: the sale of pretend items and misleading promoting.
The sale of pretend items entails presenting counterfeits (i.e., unauthorized replicas of real merchandise or manufacturers) and knockoffs (i.e., low-cost or inferior copies of genuine merchandise or manufacturers). Along with model counterfeiting, the net sale of pretend items additionally contains the substitution of low-cost or inferior objects for his or her costlier or superior counterparts. For instance, duck meat was offered as a counterfeit for beef.
Promoting faux items permits on-line shops to decrease their costs whereas attaining larger search rankings and revenue margins. Consequently, inferior items are inclined to displace superior ones, resulting in a decline in product high quality, which displays the financial idea of “Gresham’s Legislation.”
Misleading or false promoting, was known as a “malignant tumor” by Folks’s Each day. Within the on-line market, deceptive or false claims have lengthy been utilized in promotional supplies to magnify merchandise’ operate and/or efficiency.
“Brushing” (刷单), or amassing faux transactions, is one type of misleading promoting. To make picks amongst a lot of various merchandise, internet buyers rely closely on present sale quantity and buyer evaluations. By sending empty packages, on-line outlets generate faux orders and evaluations to spice up their gross sales figures, and therefore obtain larger retailer rating in customers’ search outcomes.
Throughout livestreaming periods, it is not uncommon for hosts to rent a “water military” (水军) to click on “like,” turn into followers, place orders, and put up favorable suggestions. To lure prospects, livestreamers additionally undertake a “misleading pricing” technique, providing faux reductions by fabricating the unique costs.
For actual orders, in line with China Each day, a “money again for constructive evaluations” scheme has been extensively carried out to encourage customers to go away constructive feedback by providing small money returns or reductions on future purchases.
It is usually noteworthy that each the sale of pretend merchandise and misleading promoting contain endorsements from celebrities, influencers, and pretend consultants. For instance, influencer Li Jiaqi promoted a non-stick pan regardless of eggs clearly sticking to it throughout his livestreaming session. What turned dubbed the “rollover incident” has raised doubts amongst customers about his credibility. Pretend docs, counting on replicating real docs’ content material, can shortly acquire reputation after which begin promoting low-quality and even faux health-related merchandise on these platforms.
Countermeasures on China’s On-line Retail Platforms
The Chinese language authorities has carried out a number of measures to fight misleading practices on e-commerce platforms. Within the battle towards piracy, counterfeiting, and misleading promoting, a number of legal guidelines and laws have been developed, refined, and enacted.
For instance, the revised Anti-Unfair Competitors Legislation requires e-commerce operators to chorus from falsifying merchandise’ capabilities, efficiency, high quality, gross sales quantity, or person evaluations. The E-commerce Legislation defines “brushing” as an criminality, and likewise makes retail web site operators “straight liable” for faux merchandise offered on their platforms. The Measures for the Supervision and Administration of On-line Transactions prohibits on-line companies from partaking in misleading industrial practices.
For legislation enforcement, in 2022, the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) deployed a nationwide enforcement motion towards unfair competitors, which investigated and dealt with a complete of 9,069 instances, with 739 instances referring to “brushing” and fines amounting to roughly 48.68 million yuan. The 2023 “Iron Fist” motion plan additionally highlighted counterfeiting and misleading promoting as key focus areas.
In recent times, China Customs have carried out “Dragon Motion,” “Clear Internet Motion,” and “Blue Internet Motion” to implement mental property proper (IPR) safety. In 2023, a complete of 62,000 batches of products suspected of IPR infringement had been seized, totaling 82.899 million objects for import and export.
In the meantime, extra focused measures have been adopted by on-line retail platforms. For instance, on the finish of 2015, Alibaba established the Platform Governance Division to safeguard a wholesome e-commerce ecosystem. In January 2017, the Alibaba Anti-Counterfeiting Alliance (AACA) was established to reinforce IPR safety by way of collaboration amongst a number of stakeholders. Over time, Alibaba additionally regularly innovated its IPR safety expertise system, incorporating synthetic intelligence and blockchain applied sciences.
In line with its newest annual report, by the tip of 2022, Alibaba’s mental property safety platform had safeguarded over 730,000 international emblems, assisted public safety authorities in fixing 2,123 instances, and apprehended 2,737 felony suspects.
Among the many e-commerce platforms, Pinduoduo was the primary one to introduce a “refund solely” coverage in 2021, permitting customers to obtain a refund with out returning objects that don’t align with sellers’ descriptions. Taobao, JD.com, and Douyin adopted with related refund insurance policies, prioritizing shopper rights over service provider pursuits.
It is usually noteworthy that self-employed skilled assessors are additionally rising on varied platforms, preventing towards faux merchandise and misleading promoting. Nonetheless, their motivation for exposing retailers’ misconduct is likely to be questionable: Is it pushed by a pursuit of justice or by a want for elevated consideration and community site visitors, which, ultimately, may turn into revenue by way of product promotion? Xin Jifei, referred to as “China’s most outspoken meals influencer,” additionally began promoting merchandise on-line.
Challenges and Potential Options
Regardless of the efforts made by the federal government and e-commerce platform operators, these countermeasures nonetheless face constraints that restrict their effectiveness resulting from varied challenges.
First, the substantial quantity and scale of operation make it virtually not possible to watch the outline and high quality of every product offered on-line. In line with Taobao, the variety of merchandise on the market on a single day has exceeded 800 million, with a median of 48,000 objects offered each minute. On Pinduoduo, the variety of retailers had reached 8.6 million by June 2021.
Second, some sellers are adopting new methods primarily based on loopholes, and leveraging new applied sciences and platforms to advertise faux items and conduct fraudulent actions. For instance, “brushers” could simply keep away from detection by using completely different accounts and IP (Web Protocol) addresses.
Massive knowledge and synthetic intelligence are more and more being adopted to create personalised advertising and marketing methods and to generate extra interesting content material to deceive customers. New digital financial system codecs, reminiscent of second-hand buying and selling platforms and livestreaming e-commerce, are hotbeds for misleading practices resulting from regulatory gaps.
Third, customers’ consciousness of IPR and self-protection must be additional improved, as their angle towards faux merchandise and different misleading practices considerably influences the market. In line with the White Paper on Insights into Chinese language Shoppers’ Attitudes in direction of Trademark Safety, which was launched in August 2022, 80 % of customers had a sure understanding of emblems, whereas solely 69 % of them agreed with the significance of safeguarding emblems and would guarantee their safety when making purchases.
Shoppers, particularly weak teams reminiscent of older adults, minors, and rural customers, may simply fall sufferer to buying counterfeits and/or inferior merchandise in the event that they lack consciousness of preventive methods and self-protection measures. In line with the Annual Report on the Standing of Shopper Rights Safety in China (2022), within the context of on-line promotional actions, customers exhibited indifference and default acceptance towards behaviors infringing on shopper rights.
Final however not least, some faux items offered on China’s on-line retail platforms are produced or distributed abroad. The buying and selling of counterfeit items has developed into a worldwide difficulty, involving a number of international locations throughout manufacturing, gross sales, distribution, and consumption. The disparities in varied international locations’ regulatory frameworks and enforcement capacities amplify the stress and complexities confronting China’s customs in defending IPRs.
To deal with these points, the related authorities departments ought to swiftly deal with rising regulatory gaps, increase, and improve worldwide collaboration, and additional strengthen supervision over on-line retail platforms, livestream hosts, sellers, importers, exporters, and producers by clarifying their obligations and conducting extra frequent random checks.
On-line retail platforms ought to actively cooperate with authorities supervision, and additional enhance their overview mechanisms, impose stricter person authentication, intently confirm orders and evaluations, and rigorously crack down on livestream hosts and sellers engaged in misleading practices.
To mitigate the monitoring and compliance challenges, the federal government and platforms must also collectively improve the authorized comprehension of sellers and customers, strengthen shopper rights safety consciousness, deepen their understanding of channels for safeguarding their rights, rebuild their confidence, and supply extra proactive help to customers looking for recourse.
Shoppers ought to elevate their vigilance, chorus from blindly trusting promotional supplies and present evaluations, improve consciousness of IPR and self-protection, and keep away from buying infringing merchandise. Victims ought to actively search authorized recourse, not condone unlawful behaviors, and keep a zero-tolerance angle towards fraudulent actions.
As said within the Annual Report on China’s Combating of IPR Infringement and Counterfeiting (2022), “Lengthy because the journey is, we are going to attain our vacation spot if we keep the course.”